2008 ARC Awards judge's score sheet

By Consulting Specifying Engineer Staff -- Consulting-Specifying Engineer, 5/16/2008 11:20:00 AM

Give each section of the entry points depending on how well the tactics were implemented, based on the information provided. If you think the question was not answered at all (in other words, avoided)—or if the building failed to include certain criteria of the ARC Awards, please give the section a ranking of “1 point.” Building systems (20 pts) 
Rate the solutions to the challenges posed by the building’s architectural design and site (__/10)

Rate the building’s MEP design for innovation (__/10)

Technology (16 pts) 
Rate the use of new or unusual technologies  in the following categories:

• Building controls and automation (__/2)

• Electrical distribution (__/2)

• Fire protection (__/2)

• HVAC (__/2)

• Lighting controls (__/2)

• Motors and Drives (__/2)

• Plumbing (__/2)

• Software (__/2)

Sustainability design and documentation (40 pts)

Rate the building’s energy efficiency  (__/5 design) (__/5 documentation)

Rate the building’s IAQ system  (__/5 design) (__/5 documentation)

Rate the building’s water conservation (__/5 design) (__/5 documentation)

Rate the building’s renewable energy(__/5 design) (__/5 documentation)

Integration (10 pts)
What examples of interdisciplinary integration, for example, online collaboration, BIM, etc.,  did the project offer? (__/5)

Rate the level of control system integration for this project—BAS, fire, communication, lighting, etc. (__/5) Photography (18 pts) 
Do the photos show the building’s exterior and interior? (__/2)

Do the photos show:

• Building controls and automation  (__/2)

• Electrical distribution (__/2)

• Fire protection (__/2)

• HVAC (__/2)

• Lighting controls (__/2)

• Motors and Drives (__/2)

• Plumbing (__/2)

Do the photos show specifically referenced engineered systems?  (__/2) Bonus (10 pts) 
What is the repeatability factor of the solutions from this project? (__/10) Total Building Systems points  __/20Total Technology points  __/16Total Sustainability points  __/40Total Integration points  __/10Total Photography points  __/18Total Bonus points   __/10Overall points  _/114

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» View All Talkback Threads

Related Content

• Topics
• Author

Murph on Maintenance; The Voice of Experience Chimes in on Building Systems Maintenance Costs

02/15/2010

New fire alarms for old buildings

01/31/2010

ARC Awards - Entry Received

05/05/2008

Green-lighting energy efficiency

03/17/2010

A step above

11/30/2008

Also by this author

• New electrical service center opens near nation's capital

• Data center professionals to gather in New York

• Flooded unit

• Circuit breaker panelboard

• Fiber optic connectors

Also by CSE Staff

Sponsored Links

• Resource Center
• Browse Categories
• Browse Companies

Featured Company

• SSRCx, LLC

  

  SSRCx, LLC is a commissioning provider that offers client-centered, high-quality services resulting in first class facilities and lasting relationships with builders and owners across the country. For hospitals, high-tech research labs... more

---

Most Recent Resources

• Continuous architecture for your machine software