Can data centers become energy producers?

Recovering "waste" heat from servers in data centers opens the door to innovation and efficiency.


Learning objectives

  • Provide an overview of heat-recovery systems for commercial and institutional buildings, and offer discussion on the issues pertaining to design parameters, efficiency, and opportunities to recycle energy
  • Discuss heat recovery from data centers, specifically demonstrating how data centers with water-cooled computer equipment will create highly effective energy-recycling processes.

Figure 1: This graph shows the correlation of supply and return air along with power demand for air- and water-cooled servers. Courtesy: exp U.S. ServicesThe amount and quality of recovered energy originating from HVAC systems depends on the building use and internal processes, from fume hood exhaust air in laboratories, process exhaust in industrial facilities, and toilet and other exhaust air in office buildings. The amount of heat recovered, and the first cost of the recovery equipment are the primary components when analyzing the total cost of ownership; it is important that this analysis be completed in the planning phases of the project. At a high level, the primary goal of an energy-recovery system is to transfer the recovered energy to a second system. This second system requires energy to achieve the design objective. By using the recovered energy, less purchased energy is needed.

There are many advantages in using heat recovery: 

  • Reduces energy costs: All waste heat that can be applied to another process that offsets/replaces the energy needed for the other process will reduce the overall energy use, consequently reducing utility costs. 
  • Reduces cost of capital equipment: If the overall energy use is reduced, primary equipment, such as boilers, can potentially be downsized. This will be driven by the calculated peak load and the acceptable safety margin.
  • Reduces impact on the environment: Equipment that uses fossil fuels to operate can potentially be operated at a reduced capacity assuming the heat-recovery system can meet the balance of the load. This will result in lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.

Research on heat recovery

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) published a paper on the impacts of using heat recovery in all kinds of applications, primarily in the manufacturing sector. The DOE classified the different processes into different temperature groups: low, <600°F; medium, 600 to 1,200°F; high, >1,200°F. The water temperatures in a data center will fall into the "low" category.

While it might seem that applications that fall into the "low" category will be less beneficial as compared with the other categories, the DOE reports that applications in the 77⁰ to 300⁰F temperature range represent nearly 80% of the total estimated waste heat. (Temperatures of cooling water exiting water-cooled computers will generally have water temperatures in that will range from 100⁰ to 150⁰F). Based on this, it is possible that HVAC industry will see greater opportunity and develop products and approaches that will make heat recovery in the data center more viable. Also, it is encouraging to know that the average simple payback for 19 sample heat-recovery projects is 1.5 years. 

Types of systems

There are many different methods of designing heat-recovery systems for commercial and institutional buildings. These methods cover a large variety of building types and HVAC system configurations. But as a starting point, the following examples demonstrate the core principles of energy-recovery systems: 

  • Runaround coil loop: This moves heat from the exhaust airstream to the supply airstream using two heat exchangers (finned coils) and a heat-transfer fluid, usually water or glycol. A pump is required to move the fluid through the system. A runaround coil loop is best used in situations when the airstreams are not adjacent to each other. If the temperature of the fluid heated by the exhaust air is greater than the outdoor air, energy can be recovered. However, to make this system financially feasible, the warm-water temperature must be considerably greater than the supply-air temperature. And long runs of piping add to material, installation, and energy costs (increased pump power). Generally, the economics of this system are more favorable for facilities located in colder climates that have considerable amounts of constant exhaust air.
  • Packaged energy-recovery systems: In commercial and institutional buildings, packaged energy-recovery systems are the simplest and most effective heat-reclaim solution. Many manufacturers offer products that are designed specifically to work with typical air conditioning and ventilation loads for office environments, schools, libraries, etc. One common way of implementing this type of energy-recovery system is to use air handling units with integrated heat wheels, thermosyphons, air-to-air heat exchangers, or evaporatively cooled air-to-air heat exchangers. Each one of these configurations will have different heat-transfer and efficiency characteristics and must be analyzed based on the actual loads, climate, space available, maintenance characteristics, etc.
  • Total energy wheel: Most energy-recovery devices transfer heat (sensible) energy only. An enthalpy wheel, or total energy wheel, exchanges both heat (sensible) energy and moisture (latent) energy between the supply and return airstreams. This type of wheel can be coated with a desiccant (moisture-absorbing) material and is rotated between the incoming fresh air and the return air. Heat and moisture in the return air are transferred to the wheel. During cold, dry outdoor conditions, the outside air passes over the rotating wheel, providing pre-conditioning, as the heat and moisture are transferred to the air stream. In the cooling mode, the outside air is precooled and the moisture content is lowered. These processes reduce the amount of energy required by gas-fired heating equipment and compressorized cooling equipment. 

Energy recovery in data centers

Certain types of data centers (with specific types of computer equipment) produce large amounts of usable waste heat. Supercomputing centers are a prime example having extremely high power densities (greater than 1000 W/sq ft in some cases) and liquid (water mainly) cooled computers. Heat recovery systems for these facilities prove to be very effective in reducing energy use. Because supercomputing facilities are generally purpose-built, and undergo a major evolution in technology every few years, there is room for the development of innovative solutions driven by the distinct characteristics of these data centers:

  • Much higher supply- and return-air temperatures when compared with an office building (and even other data centers). This creates greater opportunity for recovering both heating and cooling energy.
  • When the computers in the data center are water-cooled, heating energy can be recovered due to the high internal temperature in the computers.

Air-based energy recovery: Data centers that do not use water-cooled computers can still benefit from recovering energy. As long as the outside dry-bulb temperature is less than the return-air temperature, cooling energy is recoverable from the outdoor air. For example, if the design supply-air temperature for the data hall is 75⁰F and the return-air temperature is 95⁰F, when the outside air is less than 95°F there will be a reduction in cooling energy. And knowing there are many domestic and international locations that have very few hours per year that exceed 95⁰F, it becomes clear that this type of energy-recovery approach can be very efficient.

Even more efficient, at 75⁰F outdoor air, very little (if any) mechanical cooling energy is needed. Consider that in Seattle, there are 8,516 hours below 75⁰F (97%); in Chicago, 7,614 hours (87%); in Miami, 3,041 hours (35%). As with many other energy efficiency schemes, the climate plays a very important role in the overall effectiveness of the approach.

Water-based heat recovery: Many of the energy-recovery techniques discussed so far (both air- and water-based), are applicable to air handling systems using exhaust/return- and supply-air arrangements. However, depending on the facility type, it also is possible to recover energy from other types of processes that use water to cool the internal components of equipment, then transfer the heat to another process. Historically instead of recovering the heat in these processes, heat has typically been rejected to the outside, losing recoverable energy.

In data centers, water-cooled computers enable hydronic heat-recovery options. There are several options for cooling computers with water (some of these solutions also work with refrigerant in lieu of water): 

  • IT cabinets with integral chilled-water fan coil units (side cars).
  • Rear-door chilled-water heat exchangers, with or without fans, mounted on the back of the IT cabinet.
  • An IT cabinet and servers that have built-in thermal planes. When the servers are installed into the cabinet, the planes contact one-another enabling heat transfer from the server to the circulating cooling water.
  • Internal heat sinks mounted directly to the server's central processing unit (CPU), dual in-line memory modules (DIMM), and the graphics processing unit (GPU). The heat sinks are cooled directly by the water, without additional intermediate heat exchangers. Since the cooling water contacts the sources of heat directly (via heat sinks) the process is very efficient.

As an example, the water that cools the computers will be heated up to around 150⁰F. This temperature water can be used for a wide variety of things-increasing the feedwater temperature for boilers, heating a swimming pool, supplementing a district heating system, and even providing heat to temper an indoor arboretum.

Hydronic energy recovery

When planning a heat-recovery system using water-cooled computers, it is essential to determine the expected temperatures in the energy-recovery water loop. The temperature is a function of how "hard" the computers are working. Generally, as the workload increases, the temperature of the CPUs, GPUs, and DIMMs begin to increase, resulting in greater heat output. Ultimately, the water temperature in the energy-recovery loop is determined by several variables, and because the amount of energy recovered from computers is not constant, care must be taken in estimating the amount of energy that can be recovered. 

External factors impacting the design approach

Recovering heat from computers will end up as a purely academic exercise unless the recovered heat can actually be used elsewhere. Viability must be assessed using long-term savings and short-term costs. The total cost of ownership (TCO), which includes any necessary modifications to existing hydronic systems, must show promise in terms of financial and commercial viability for the project to succeed.

ASHRAE Thermal Guidelines for Data Processing Environments has a section on water-cooled computers and contains a table on water-temperature classes, with each class having a facility cooling-water temperature range from minimum to maximum inlet temperatures. It is necessary to have this information when discussing data center temperatures with the technology planners and thermal engineers. (Note that the temperature ranges for water-cooled computers are higher than the inlet temperatures for air-cooled computers.) When the heat is removed directly from the motherboard components, the heat transfer is more effective and creates a more controlled heat-removal process.

Figure 1 can assist in determining the inlet and outlet water temperatures of the heat-recovery loops. The data shows how the inlet temperature and system power (which correlates to the workload intensity) affect the discharge temperature. In this example, the discharge temperatures range from 100⁰ to 130⁰F; if this computer were water-cooled, these values would change, but the concept still applies. 

<< First < Previous Page 1 Page 2 Next > Last >>

Product of the Year
Consulting-Specifying Engineer's Product of the Year (POY) contest is the premier award for new products in the HVAC, fire, electrical, and...
40 Under Forty: Get Recognized
Consulting-Specifying Engineer magazine is dedicated to encouraging and recognizing the most talented young individuals...
MEP Giants Program
The MEP Giants program lists the top mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and fire protection engineering firms in the United States.
November 2018
Emergency power requirements, salary survey results, lighting controls, fire pumps, healthcare facilities, and more
October 2018
Approaches to building engineering, 2018 Commissioning Giants, integrated project delivery, improving construction efficiency, an IPD primer, collaborative projects, NFPA 13 sprinkler systems.
September 2018
Power boiler control, Product of the Year, power generation,and integration and interoperability
Data Centers: Impacts of Climate and Cooling Technology
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
Safety First: Arc Flash 101
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
Critical Power: Hospital Electrical Systems
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
Data Center Design
Data centers, data closets, edge and cloud computing, co-location facilities, and similar topics are among the fastest-changing in the industry.
click me