Turning Up the Heat on Legionella

When Legionnaires' Disease first appeared in 1976, researchers pointed to a faulty air-conditioning system as the source of the bacteria. But over the years, the finger of guilt has turned away from HVAC—and toward plumbing. "The overwhelming majority of LD cases have been traced to potable hot water systems," said David Yates, a plumbing contractor and owner of F.

08/01/2003


When Legionnaires' Disease first appeared in 1976, researchers pointed to a faulty air-conditioning system as the source of the bacteria. But over the years, the finger of guilt has turned away from HVAC—and toward plumbing. "The overwhelming majority of LD cases have been traced to potable hot water systems," said David Yates, a plumbing contractor and owner of F.W. Behler, a contracting company in York, Pa. "There is a growing belief that the original outbreak in Philadelphia was also a result of the potable water being contaminated."

It turns out that hot water systems are the perfect breeding ground for Legionella. While not a major health threat to everyone, Legionella can be deadly for the elderly, people with compromised immune systems and people suffering from chronic diseases. This makes hospitals and nursing homes especially vulnerable. In 1999, several patients in Maryland health-care facilities caught LD. A 2000 report by Maryland's Dept. of Health and Mental Hygiene attributed the cases to potable hot water systems, and cited several problems.

According to the report, the bacteria thrive in temperatures ranging from 77

Yates said that organizations such as the National Safe Kids Campaign have pushed for water temperatures to be set at 120°F to prevent scalding. But this would only prolong the length of time it took for water to scald and wouldn't kill Legionella. He explained that water needs to be at least 140°F to make sure Legionella died off.

Water heaters are another trouble spot. They can develop layers of water at different temperatures. "Kind of like a stack of hot cakes," Yates said.

Once Legionella has entered a potable water system, it's notoriously hard to get rid of. The bacteria can hide from high-temperature system flushes, even ones as long as 30 minutes, by hunkering down in the biofilms that line most pipes. Chlorine shock treatments don't work well either. "Chlorine is ineffective against Legionella at levels safe for human contact," Yates said. "It does not penetrate biofilms very well and at high percentages will combine with any organic matter to create chloramines, which are carcinogenic."

So what can engineers do? The answer starts with prevention. A few simple additions to the potable water system will encourage owners to keep the water temperatures high enough to kill legionella. Yates recommended installing a thermostatic American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) 1017 listed device at the point of source outlet to eliminate stacking in the tank, temperature fluctuations or a thermostat overrun. He also suggested installing an ASSE 1016 scald guard device at all points of use. Yates said distribution systems should be outfitted with constant circulation, which could be granted an exemption from energy conservation if it were installed using a low wattage pump and adequately insulated distribution lines.

In buildings where a radiant heat system is called for, the system should always be closed, never a combined or "open" one that connects the potable water system to the radiant heat pipes, Yates said. Stagnant water and high pH levels in radiant pipes amplify an already Legionella-friendly environment. If both systems are connected, there is almost no way to keep the bacteria out of the drinking water. "Open systems offer but one benefit—they're cheaper," said Yates.

Educating decision-makers and the public about the dangers of open systems and Legionella in general is the only way to ensure safety, Yates said. You can find out more about Legionella and plumbing systems, including an analysis of treatment options, by reading the report on the Maryland cases at www.dhmh.state.md.us/html/legionella.htm .



Hostile Water

Here are some web sites with information on Legionellosis:

A group of experts on the disease offer their knowledge at

The Legionella Water Testing Lab can be accessed at

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) provides information at

The Association of Water Technologies has posted a paper on Legionella at



No comments
Consulting-Specifying Engineer's Product of the Year (POY) contest is the premier award for new products in the HVAC, fire, electrical, and...
Consulting-Specifying Engineer magazine is dedicated to encouraging and recognizing the most talented young individuals...
The MEP Giants program lists the top mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and fire protection engineering firms in the United States.
Combined heat and power; Assessing replacement of electrical systems; Energy codes and lighting; Salary Survey; Fan efficiency
Commissioning lighting control systems; 2016 Commissioning Giants; Design high-efficiency hot water systems for hospitals; Evaluating condensation and condensate
Solving HVAC challenges; Thermal comfort criteria; Liquid-immersion cooling; Specifying VRF systems; 2016 Product of the Year winners
Driving motor efficiency; Preventing Arc Flash in mission critical facilities; Integrating alternative power and existing electrical systems
Putting COPS into context; Designing medium-voltage electrical systems; Planning and designing resilient, efficient data centers; The nine steps of designing generator fuel systems
Designing generator systems; Using online commissioning tools; Selective coordination best practices
As brand protection manager for Eaton’s Electrical Sector, Tom Grace oversees counterfeit awareness...
Amara Rozgus is chief editor and content manager of Consulting-Specifier Engineer magazine.
IEEE power industry experts bring their combined experience in the electrical power industry...
Michael Heinsdorf, P.E., LEED AP, CDT is an Engineering Specification Writer at ARCOM MasterSpec.
click me