Lighting control basics: occupancy and vacancy sensors explained

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance.

06/24/2016


In a high-performance office building, lighting can account for 20% of energy use. Properly applied, lighting controls can easily reduce that portion by 25%. But, as with any high-performance strategy, there are subtleties to the technology and application. In this article, we'll explain the basics of occupancy sensors and their important counterpart, the vacancy sensor.

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance. However, when using some of the older-technology sensors, or when using sensors in inappropriate conditions, the results can be undesirable and uncomfortable for occupants.

Because of inappropriate use of inferior sensor technology in the past, there is a perception among users that occupancy sensors do not work well. Newer technologies are rapidly turning that perception around to where we see virtually no occupant complaints regarding sensor use. The widespread use of dual-technology sensors have almost completely eliminated the common misperception that the lights will turn off while an occupant is present but sitting still. Below is a discussion of the basics of occupancy sensor technology.

Passive infrared motion detection

Passive infrared (PIR) occupancy sensors are best for detecting major motions like an occupant walking through a space. PIR works by detecting movement of heat sources in the space. It only detects heat in its direct range of view.

Advantages: cheap, small form factor, low power requirements, and great for wireless applications.

Limitations: coverage is directional and limited to line of sight; detects only major movement, so prone to a "false off."

The illustration below shows where a PIR sensor would detect major motion and trigger lights in an open-office space. The benefit is that a person walking in the room next to the space would not trigger the lights to turn on, but the drawback is that only major motion is detected.

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance. Courtesy: Glumac

Ultrasonic motion detection

Ultrasonic technology in occupancy sensors is excellent for minor motion detection. This makes ultrasonic a good option where small movements, such as typing at a computer desk, take place for extended periods of time. Ultrasonic works by emitting a pulse into the space and receiving the bounceback. When there is movement in the space, the bounceback is read differently and the sensor knows there is movement in the space. This technology is capable of "seeing" around corners.

Advantages: can see around objects, detects minor movements.

Limitations: requires location-specific commissioning, has higher power requirements, prone to false-on triggers.

The illustration below shows the much broader sensing area of an ultrasonic detector as compared with the PIR illustration above.

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance. Courtesy: Glumac

Dual-tech motion detection

Dual-tech combines both ultrasonic and PIR sensor technologies to provide optimal detection with minimal false alarms. The occupancy sensor will not turn on the lighting until both PIR and ultrasonic elements are triggered. The benefit here is that the minor motions of typing at a computer are picked up with the ultrasonic technology, but the lights aren't turned on from movement of a person in a different room based on ultrasonic bounces. In addition, once the light is turned on, the sensor only needs one of the technologies to keep the lights on. This helps ensure the lighting is not turned off while the occupant is in the space.

Advantages: detects both major and minor movements, limits false on and false off.

Limitations: higher price, though the discrepancy is small and diminishing.

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance. Courtesy: Glumac

Key insight: occupancy vs. vacancy sensors

Use of occupancy sensors in a daylit space can mean that lights come on when they are not needed. In these conditions, a change of the control sequence can shift the operation from an occupancy sensor to a much more useful vacancy sensor. Vacancy sensors assume that a user will turn the lights on manually, typically via a wall switch. The vacancy sensor will then monitor the space to turn lights off if the space is then vacant for a specified length of time.

Occupants in daylit spaces often need no additional electric lighting to perform basic tasks. Glumac lighting designers have found that lighting energy use will decrease when users are given control of their lighting and access to daylight, because lights will only be turned on when needed. Further, sensor operation in a vacancy sensor scenario is much less obtrusive than with an occupancy sensor. The only time users should notice that there is sensor control is when they come back to a space to find the lights turned off automatically.

Using the standard "automatic-on" occupancy sensors within most spaces that have no natural light makes sense because the lights should always be needed when someone enters, as there is no other light source in the space. But for spaces with daylight, the "automatic-off" of vacancy sensors is typically preferable.

Occupancy sensors have been around for decades and, when used correctly, can be a highly efficient means for saving energy, reducing light trespass, increasing security and lamp life, and decreasing fixture maintenance. Courtesy: Glumac

Recommendations

The goals of integrating appropriate lighting controls into any design are to improve comfort and usability for occupants and to decrease lighting energy use. When properly understood and applied, occupancy and vacancy sensors can do both. To sum up the basics:

  • Seek dual-technology sensors whenever the budget allows.
  • Dual-technology occupancy sensors are recommended in most interior spaces with no available daylight.
  • Dual-technology vacancy sensors are recommended in most perimeter spaces with available daylight.

-Christine Culver, is a lighting designer with Glumac. This article originally appeared on www.glumac.com. Glumac is a CFE Media content partner.



Jozef , Non-US/Not Applicable, Poland, 07/21/16 05:05 PM:

I cannot agree with Christine, In my professional work I have to make inventory of power using in high rise building taking power value from electric meters. On my list the lighting power using was responsible for higher level of consumption. It was near to 40% of total power consumption of high rise buildings next was HVAC -43%.
Christine was the lighting Designer so she has no access to power data consumption.
Consulting-Specifying Engineer's Product of the Year (POY) contest is the premier award for new products in the HVAC, fire, electrical, and...
Consulting-Specifying Engineer magazine is dedicated to encouraging and recognizing the most talented young individuals...
The MEP Giants program lists the top mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and fire protection engineering firms in the United States.
Combined heat and power; Assessing replacement of electrical systems; Energy codes and lighting; Salary Survey; Fan efficiency
Commissioning lighting control systems; 2016 Commissioning Giants; Design high-efficiency hot water systems for hospitals; Evaluating condensation and condensate
Solving HVAC challenges; Thermal comfort criteria; Liquid-immersion cooling; Specifying VRF systems; 2016 Product of the Year winners
Driving motor efficiency; Preventing Arc Flash in mission critical facilities; Integrating alternative power and existing electrical systems
Putting COPS into context; Designing medium-voltage electrical systems; Planning and designing resilient, efficient data centers; The nine steps of designing generator fuel systems
Designing generator systems; Using online commissioning tools; Selective coordination best practices
As brand protection manager for Eaton’s Electrical Sector, Tom Grace oversees counterfeit awareness...
Amara Rozgus is chief editor and content manager of Consulting-Specifier Engineer magazine.
IEEE power industry experts bring their combined experience in the electrical power industry...
Michael Heinsdorf, P.E., LEED AP, CDT is an Engineering Specification Writer at ARCOM MasterSpec.
click me